Some of the Best Music Expresses Nothing at All

I've been listening to a lot of J. S. Bach lately, as well as bits of Thomas Tallis, Josquin, and similar pre-Classical Era composers. Often as I listen to these pieces of music, I find myself thinking: this music expresses nothing.

The power of a piece like this may well be that it can't be broken down into any kind of meaning other than the meaning that it seems to have as we hear it unfold. Perhaps that helps to explain why, even as it has no message, it still seems to express information that seems both deep and somehow true as well.

In any case, I have become addicted to the experience of listening to these pieces and searching for the meaning in them. I never find anything I can really point to, but that's meaningful in and of itself, just like the experience, say, of looking at a tree might be. What do I make of a tree? What does it express? Everything and nothing, I suppose.

I've made a station for you. It's called "Inexpressible Radio." Take a listen and ask yourself: what is this music saying? If it says nothing, then why does it also seem to make so much sense?


6 things I bet you will notice:

1. The pieces are beautiful.
2. The pieces are extraordinary things for a person to have conceived and written.
3. The pieces are evidence that the people who lived centuries ago may not have been all that different from us.
4. The pieces that have no words (especially the solo piano pieces) are the ones that seem most abstract. They seem to be full of a kind of meaning as you are listening to them, but once they are done, there seems to be no takeaway message.
5. The choral pieces seem more expressive than the solo piano pieces do.
6. Listening to these pieces of music is a really great way to spend some time!

I hope you enjoy and find some new music, and I'll look forward to your comments.

Peter Himmelman's dusky baritone, live at Pandora

Minnesota-based songwriter Peter Himmelman has had an intriguing and varied career. He started out in MPLS working with R&B crooner Alexander O'Neal, and over time brought his own dusky baritone to work in support of his soulful and thoroughly American songwriting. He writes and produces original albums of children's music as well. What we didn't realize is what a crack-up Himmelman is, as you'll see in these interviews.

"Georgia Clay"

"Sit Tight"

"Phone Call From Chicago"

"Been Set Free"

Mike Seeger's Old Time Music

The music that we're speaking of is a cultural resource that we've built up over thousands of years... Before we had radio and phonographs... The music from these earlier, old times endured through the generations because of its rich and varied sounds and lyrics and because it filled the needs of the people, who, after all, created it for themselves. - Mike Seeger

As many of you probably know, Mike Seeger died on August 7. I've been listening to some of his work and thought it would be cool to have some company, so I've made a station called Mike Seeger's Old Time Dream, based on our collections of Mike Seeger's music as well as our collection of the New Lost City Ramblers, the group that he founded and played with for more than 50 years.

Mike Seeger was a key participant and leader in the "old time music" movement, and if you're not familiar with this music, you're on the threshold of a very cool discovery. Even if you ultimately decide you don't particularly like it (doubtful, I bet), old time music's acoustic instrumentation, rough performances, and old shared songs preserve a powerful way of making music (and perhaps of living).

Old time music lets us hear the sound of music as it must have been before recordings were common. Back when performances would have been more idiosyncratic, less standardized, and would have come out in the same ways of speaking and being that the people used in everyday life.

It also takes old, unattributed songs as a main part of its repertoire. These days, assuming someone wanted to write those kinds of songs, modern copyright laws might make sharing them difficult, at least in their recorded form. But songs that were shared freely in the ongoing, practical use and performance of the songs by people in their homes would live on, as the traditional repertoire has for so long.

Mike Seeger's Old Time Dream, indeed.

There is so much to hear and ask about this music, but I'll beg off here and let Mike Seeger do the real work. Looking forward to hearing comments, and thanks for reading and listening!